---
title: Score the role before you score the person | Nobu Sato
description: Hackman and Oldham score the role itself on five dimensions. A low-scoring role keeps nobody. Score the role before hiring; if it is low, redesign it first.
image: https://nobusato.jp/hubfs/score-the-role-before-the-person-en.png
---

[Nobu Sato](https://nobusato.jp/en?hsLang=en)

[Home](https://nobusato.jp/en?hsLang=en) [Profile](https://nobusato.jp/en/profile?hsLang=en) [Articles](https://nobusato.jp/en/blog?hsLang=en) [Contact](https://nobusato.jp/en/contact?hsLang=en)

[日本語](https://nobusato.jp/ja/blog/score-the-role-before-the-person)[English](https://nobusato.jp/en/blog/score-the-role-before-the-person)[中文](https://nobusato.jp/zh/blog/score-the-role-before-the-person)

[Organizations & Hiring](https://nobusato.jp/en/blog/tag/organizations-hiring)

# Score the role before you score the person

[Nobu Sato](https://nobusato.jp/en/profile?hsLang=en)

![Score the rolebefore you scorethe person](https://nobusato.jp/hs-fs/hubfs/score-the-role-before-the-person-en.png?width=1200&height=630&name=score-the-role-before-the-person-en.png)

**Series「People Don't Follow the Org Chart」** · Part 12 of 13 · Part 3 · Why people put in effort  
Prologue：[The people who aren't on the org chart](https://nobusato.jp/en/blog/people-not-on-the-org-chart?hsLang=en)

One role turns over three people in two years, each leaving for a different stated reason: no growth, too fragmented, can't see what the work is for. The company concludes its hiring bar needs raising. My conclusion: the three were saying the same thing, and the role itself fails the test.

## Five dimensions for scoring a role

In 1976 Richard Hackman and Greg Oldham proposed the job characteristics model, which breaks "can this role, by itself, engage a person" into five scorable dimensions.

Skill variety: how many different abilities the role uses. Task identity: whether the person does a whole piece of work or a fragment. Task significance: how much the work affects other people. Autonomy: how much of the how and when is the person's own decision. Feedback: whether, on finishing, the work itself tells you how well it went.

The first three determine whether the work feels meaningful, the fourth determines felt responsibility, the fifth determines knowledge of results. A role low on all five loses anyone's engagement within six to twelve months, largely regardless of who they are.

The model has over forty years of empirical support. The disputes are two: whether the five dimensions carry equal weight (the original used a multiplicative formula; most later research uses simple addition), and individual differences (some people are less sensitive to the five). Neither dispute affects its use as a checklist.

Skill varietyHow many abilities used4/5Task identityWhole piece or fragment1/5Task significanceEffect on others2/5AutonomyHow much is their call1/5FeedbackDoes the work tell you1/5Example: HQ liaison role 9/25, redesign before hiring

**Fig.1**Score each dimension 1 to 5. The example is a typical HQ liaison role: 9 in total, below the line of 15.

## What low-scoring roles look like in a Japan entity

The most common is the HQ liaison role: all day translating HQ's requests to local and local conditions back to HQ. Skill variety is high, but task identity is near zero (always relaying someone else's work), autonomy is low (neither side's decisions are theirs), feedback is low (success belongs to both sides, failure is their poor communication). I wrote about this role in [the structural-hole post](https://nobusato.jp/en/blog/bilingual-staff-are-not-translators?hsLang=en); it scores low because it was never given decision rights.

The second is the role cut too fine. HQ slices roles for its own thousands-strong division of labor and transplants them into a five-person entity: one person reviews only one type of contract, another only enters data into one system. Task identity and significance are both low; the person can't see how their sliver relates to the company.

The third is the role with no feedback. Japanese companies often give an annual evaluation once at year-end, and for the other eleven months people don't know how they're doing. That is a structural absence of feedback, not a boss who can't communicate.

## The design decision: score before hiring, fix low roles first

Add the five dimensions to the role profile and fill them in before writing the job requirements. Score each 1 to 5. A role totaling under 15 doesn't get a hire; it gets redesigned first.

The fixes are usually concrete. Low task identity: pull one or two upstream or downstream steps into the role so the person owns something end to end, even if it's smaller. Low autonomy: write down three things they can decide without asking, the same move as [the autonomy item](https://nobusato.jp/en/blog/motivation-is-a-design-decision?hsLang=en). Low feedback: give the role one metric the person can see themselves, updated weekly, not at year-end. Low significance: put them in front of the people who receive their work, even once a quarter.

Score again after the redesign, and hire only once it clears the line. Reverse the order and you get the three-people-in-two-years story.

## Back to the method

When I judge person-role fit, I check veto items first and then the weakest layer. But there's a step before that: does the role itself clear the line? If it doesn't, however finely you assess fit, you're just looking for someone who will tolerate a bad role. These five dimensions are page one of my role profile; the candidate's four-layer portrait is page two.

The role in your company with the highest turnover: what do its five dimensions add up to?

**In this series**  
Previous：[Pay removes complaints. It doesn't create commitment.](https://nobusato.jp/en/blog/herzberg-pay-removes-complaints?hsLang=en)  
Next：[When bad news stops traveling up](https://nobusato.jp/en/blog/psychological-safety-bad-news?hsLang=en)

---

Shorter notes that don't make it into a full article go on LinkedIn. [Follow me there](https://www.linkedin.com/in/realnobusato/).

## More in this column

- ### [Pay removes complaints. It doesn't create commitment.](https://nobusato.jp/en/blog/herzberg-pay-removes-complaints?hsLang=en)
  
  Herzberg: what causes complaints and what creates commitment are different sets. Pay is hygiene; enough of it buys no ...
- ### [Motivation is a design decision](https://nobusato.jp/en/blog/motivation-is-a-design-decision?hsLang=en)
  
  Self-determination theory: autonomy, competence, relatedness. Each maps to a design decision: reporting lines, grade ...
- ### [Add people, and each one pulls less](https://nobusato.jp/en/blog/ringelmann-effect-add-people-pull-less?hsLang=en)
  
  The Ringelmann effect: eight on a rope pull half of what they would alone. Coordination loss plus motivation loss. The ...

[← All articles](https://nobusato.jp/en/blog?hsLang=en)

## Writing about launching in Japan, in three languages.

[Profile](https://nobusato.jp/en/profile?hsLang=en) [Get in touch](https://nobusato.jp/en/contact?hsLang=en)

Nobu Sato

Writing about launching in Japan, in three languages.

[info@nobusato.jp](mailto:info@nobusato.jp) [LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/in/realnobusato/) [X](https://x.com/nobusato5888)

© 2026 Nobu Sato. All rights reserved.

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BreadcrumbList",
  "itemListElement" : [ {
    "@type" : "ListItem",
    "item" : "https://nobusato.jp/en",
    "name" : "Home",
    "position" : 1
  }, {
    "@type" : "ListItem",
    "item" : "https://nobusato.jp/en/blog",
    "name" : "Articles",
    "position" : 2
  }, {
    "@type" : "ListItem",
    "item" : "https://nobusato.jp/en/blog/score-the-role-before-the-person",
    "name" : "Score the role before you score the person",
    "position" : 3
  } ]
}
```

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@id" : "https://nobusato.jp/en/blog/score-the-role-before-the-person",
  "@type" : "WebPage",
  "author" : {
    "@id" : "https://nobusato.jp/#person"
  },
  "inLanguage" : "en",
  "isPartOf" : {
    "@id" : "https://nobusato.jp/en/blog",
    "@type" : "Blog",
    "name" : "Articles"
  },
  "name" : "Score the role before you score the person",
  "url" : "https://nobusato.jp/en/blog/score-the-role-before-the-person"
}
```

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@id" : "https://nobusato.jp/#person",
  "@type" : "Person",
  "name" : "Nobu Sato",
  "sameAs" : [ "https://www.linkedin.com/in/realnobusato/", "https://x.com/nobusato5888" ],
  "url" : "https://nobusato.jp/en/profile"
}
```

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Nobu Sato",
    "url" : "https://nobusato.jp/en/blog/author/nobu-sato"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-10-24T02:22:23.425Z",
  "datePublished" : "2026-10-24T02:22:23.000Z",
  "headline" : "Score the role before you score the person",
  "image" : [ "https://nobusato.jp/hubfs/score-the-role-before-the-person-en.png" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://nobusato.jp/en/blog/score-the-role-before-the-person",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://nobusato.jp/hubfs/nobusatojp-1.jpg"
    },
    "name" : "nobusato.jp"
  }
}
```